2024 Topps Signature Class Football Guide – NFL Break Values and Team ROI Rankings
Below we rank all 32 NFL teams by expected break ROI (autograph hit potential and card value) and long-term prospect upside in 2024 Topps Signature Class Football. Each team section highlights key autograph signers (primarily 2024 rookies, plus notable veterans/legends), along with scouting notes and an investment recommendation (Buy/Hold/Sell). The focus is on rookie autographs from the 2024 NFL Draft class, weighted heavily toward their hobby appeal.
Table – 2024 Topps Signature Team Break Value Rankings (1 = highest ROI, 32 = lowest):
| Rank | Team | Key Autographs | Rookie Class Strength | Rec. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New England Patriots | QB Drake Maye, QB Tom Brady, TE Rob Gronkowski, DB Ty Law | Elite QB prospect; GOAT veteran auto | Buy |
| 2 | Chicago Bears | QB Caleb Williams, WR Rome Odunze, LB Mike Singletary (85 Bears Triple) | Generational #1 pick QB; solid WR | Hold |
| 3 | Washington Commanders | QB Jayden Daniels, CB Mike Sainristil, DT Jer’Zhan Newton | Dynamic franchise QB; deep class | Buy |
| 4 | Arizona Cardinals | WR Marvin Harrison Jr., QB Kurt Warner, RB Trey Benson | Top WR prospect (4th overall); decent depth | Buy |
| 5 | Las Vegas Raiders | TE Brock Bowers, OL Jackson Powers-Johnson, LB DJ Glaze | Rookie All-Pro TE (112 rec, 1,194 yd); O-line help | Buy |
| 6 | Denver Broncos | QB Bo Nix, QB John Elway, RB Terrell Davis | 1st-round QB to groom; Elway legend auto | Hold |
| 7 | Minnesota Vikings | EDGE Dallas Turner, WR Randy Moss, RB Adrian Peterson | Athletic edge (17th pick) vikings.com; multiple HOF autos | Hold |
| 8 | Indianapolis Colts | WR Adonai Mitchell, QB Anthony Richardson, QB Peyton Manning | Promising WR; injured 2023 QB returning; Peyton auto | Buy |
| 9 | New York Giants | WR Malik Nabers, QB Eli Manning, LB Lawrence Taylor | Explosive WR (4.35 speed) foxsports.com; Giants legend autos | Hold |
| 10 | Detroit Lions | RB Blake Corum, RB Barry Sanders, WR Herman Moore | Strong RB prospect; Barry Sanders auto (high appeal) | Hold |
| 11 | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | RB Bucky Irving, QB Michael Pratt, QB Doug Williams | Elusive RB (NFL-best 35.8% missed tackles); fan-fave QB auto | Hold |
| 12 | San Francisco 49ers | QB Joe Montana, WR Jerry Rice, QB Brock Purdy (2nd-year) | Iconic Montana/Rice autos; no top 2024 rookies | Buy |
| 13 | Dallas Cowboys | RB Deuce Vaughn, RB Emmitt Smith, DT Randy White | Limited rookies; Emmitt Smith auto draws fans | Hold |
| 14 | Miami Dolphins | RB MarShawn Lloyd, QB Dan Marino, DE Jason Taylor | Raw RB prospect; Marino legend auto (perennial demand) | Hold |
| 15 | Philadelphia Eagles | DB Cooper DeJean, S Brian Dawkins, QB Donovan McNabb | Top defensive rookies; Dawkins/McNabb autos for fans | Hold |
| 16 | Buffalo Bills | WR Keon Coleman, QB Jim Kelly, RB Thurman Thomas | Big WR prospect; Kelly/Thurman autos (90s legends) | Hold |
| 17 | Pittsburgh Steelers | LB Nick Herbig, WR Hines Ward, DB Rod Woodson | Mid-tier rookies; popular Steeler legend autos | Hold |
| 18 | Tennessee Titans | DL T’Vondre Sweat, RB Earl Campbell, QB Warren Moon | Solid DL; Oilers HOF autos (Campbell, Moon) | Hold |
| 19 | Los Angeles Rams | DT Braden Fiske, WR Isaac Bruce, RB Eric Dickerson | High-performing rookies (no hobby stars); Bruce auto | Hold |
| 20 | Baltimore Ravens | LB Trenton Simpson, LB Ray Lewis, DB Rod Woodson | Hard-nosed rookies; Ray Lewis auto (popular) | Hold |
| 21 | Atlanta Falcons | LB Bralen Trice, QB Michael Vick, WR Andre Rison | Role-player rookies; Vick autograph intrigue | Hold |
| 22 | Kansas City Chiefs | DB Chamari Conner, KR Dante Hall, RB Larry Johnson | Thin rookie crop; minor vet autos (no Mahomes cards) | Sell |
| 23 | Cincinnati Bengals | TE Josh Whyle, QB Boomer Esiason, OT Anthony Muñoz | Minimal rookies; ’80s Bengals autos (niche appeal) | Sell |
| 24 | Seattle Seahawks | LB Tyrice Knight, WR Steve Largent, CB Richard Sherman | Low-impact rookies; Largent/Sherman autos (moderate) | Sell |
| 25 | Green Bay Packers | RB Lew Nichols III, RB AJ Dillon (vet), LB Clay Matthews | Unremarkable rookies; no Favre/Rodgers autos | Sell |
| 26 | New Orleans Saints | CB Kool-Aid McKinstry, QB Spencer Rattler, LB Rickey Jackson | 1st-round CB & project QB; few big-name signers | Sell |
| 27 | Carolina Panthers | TE Ja’Tavion Sanders, WR Muhsin Muhammad, LB Luke Kuechly | Athletic TE for Bryce; minor vet autos | Sell |
| 28 | Cleveland Browns | DT Mike Hall Jr., QB Bernie Kosar, KR Josh Cribbs | Depth rookies; limited collector appeal on autos | Sell |
| 29 | Houston Texans | QB Kedon Slovis, RB Arian Foster, LB Nathaniel Watson | No 1st-rounder; Arian Foster auto (nostalgia only) | Sell |
| 30 | New York Jets | OT Olu Fashanu (proj.), QB Vinny Testaverde, WR Wayne Chrebet | Likely OL pick; no Rodgers/Wilson autos | Sell |
| 31 | Los Angeles Chargers | OT Joe Alt, LB Junior Seau (if present), TE Kellen Winslow Sr. | Top-5 OT rookie (low hobby value); few notable autos | Sell |
| 32 | Jacksonville Jaguars | OT Graham Barton, RB Fred Taylor, QB Mark Brunell | Few rookie draws; sparse veteran signers | Sell |
Investment Recommendation Key: Buy = target this team (undervalued or high upside in breaks); Hold = fair value, reasonable upside; Sell = avoid or sell off (overpriced or low upside).
2024 Topps Signature Buy or Hold Insights
1. New England Patriots – Buy
Key autos: Drake Maye (QB); Tom Brady (QB); Rob Gronkowski (TE); Ty Law (DB)
2024 Rookies: The Patriots landed QB Drake Maye at 3rd overall, giving them a new franchise signal-caller. Maye’s rookie stats were modest, but he flashed elite arm strength, mobility and poise even in a poor offensive environment. With an improved supporting cast, his ceiling remains extremely high. Fellow rookie Ja’Lynn Polk (WR) showed glimpses as well.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: The Patriots are a top-tier break spot thanks to Maye’s rookie autographs and the inclusion of Tom Brady autographs in this product. Brady’s autos are holy grails for many collectors, providing immediate high-dollar hits. The combination of a Tier-1 rookie QB and the GOAT QB’s signature gives New England enormous hit potential.
Long-term upside: Maye is viewed as an “enticing quarterback to build a franchise around,” surviving a tough Year 1 while showcasing the traits of a future star. If he blossoms, his card values will rise accordingly. New England’s hobby appeal is further bolstered by its legacy stars (Brady, Gronk).
Recommendation: Buy. Patriots spots won’t be cheap, but they offer a rare convergence of a top rookie quarterback and premium veteran autos. The upside justifies the price – grab and hold for Maye’s development and the perennial Brady premium.
2. Chicago Bears – Hold
Key autos: Caleb Williams (QB); Rome Odunze (WR); Mike Singletary/Richard Dent/Dan Hampton (’85 Bears Triple); Jim McMahon (QB)
2024 Rookies: Chicago nabbed QB Caleb Williams #1 overall and WR Rome Odunze #9, injecting star power into their offense. Williams entered as one of the most “ballyhooed” QB prospects in recent memory. He showed spurts of brilliance – setting Bears rookie records for 3,541 passing yards and 20 TDs – but also struggled with consistency behind a leaky line (league-high 68 sacks). Odunze had a quiet 54/734/3 debut amid a crowded veteran receiving corps. Still, both rookies retain immense upside.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: The Bears offer the hobby’s most coveted rookie in Caleb Williams. His autographs carry huge hype as collectors chase the potential next superstar. Chicago also has a rare triple-auto of ’85 Bears legends (Singletary/Dent/Hampton) and a McMahon auto, adding nostalgic value. However, beyond Caleb, the checklist depth is average – Odunze is solid but WRs generally draw less frenzy than QBs.
Long-term upside: Williams is still viewed as a generational talent despite an uneven Year 1. His arm talent and athleticism are “still there” and now paired with a new offensive-minded head coach. If he evolves into a franchise QB, his cards could explode in value. Odunze’s big frame and downfield ability could translate better in Year 2 with more stable QB play.
Recommendation: Hold. The Bears are a high-upside spot thanks to Caleb, but much of that is already baked into steep prices. It’s wise to hold or selectively buy – invest if you believe in Caleb’s trajectory, but temper expectations in the short term as the market already treats him as a top-tier asset.
3. Washington Commanders – Buy
Key autos: Jayden Daniels (QB); Mike Sainristil (CB); Champ Bailey (CB, legend); Mark Rypien (QB, SB MVP)
2024 Rookies: The Commanders’ 2024 class was outstanding. QB Jayden Daniels (No. 2 overall) proved to be a home run – a dynamic dual-threat QB who injected life into the franchise. He racked up 31 total TDs and 4,394 yards, earning a Pro Bowl nod and frontrunner status for Offensive Rookie of the Year. On defense, CB Mike Sainristil (2nd Rd) and DT Jer’Zhan Newton (2nd Rd) became instant contributors in a revamped unit. This class helped fuel a remarkable Washington turnaround (from 4-13 to an NFC Championship run).
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: Daniels’ autographs have become red-hot as his on-field performance exceeded expectations. Collectors are now chasing him as the next star QB – his combo of clutch playmaking and “elite arm talent” has drawn raves. The Commanders also feature some legend autos (Champ Bailey, Mark Rypien), but the primary draw is the deep rookie autograph lineup. With six rookie autos (Daniels plus Sainristil, Newton, etc.), Washington offers plentiful hit chances.
Long-term upside: Washington’s rookie class was ranked #1 in the NFL, headlined by Daniels “giving Washington the league’s most valuable commodity: a true franchise quarterback”. His cards should appreciate if he continues on an All-Pro trajectory. The defensive rookies add to the team’s future but won’t individually drive hobby value (defenders typically have lower card demand). Still, their success boosts the team’s narrative and Daniels’ winning prospects.
Recommendation: Buy. The Commanders deliver both quantity and quality in autographs. Daniels looks like the real deal, and his market is ascending fast. Snag Washington spots – you’re betting on a budding superstar at QB, with plenty of other autos as gravy in breaks.
4. Arizona Cardinals – Buy
Key autos: Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR); Kurt Warner (QB); Trey Benson (RB)
2024 Rookies: Arizona invested their top pick (No. 4 overall) in Marvin Harrison Jr., widely regarded as a generational WR talent. Harrison Jr. has size, pedigree, and polished route-running – he was the consensus WR1 of the class and did not disappoint as a rookie playmaker. The Cardinals’ class also featured RB Trey Benson and DL Darius Robinson, but Harrison Jr.’s presence defines it. He immediately became a focal point of the offense with flashes of the dominance he showed at Ohio State.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: Marvin Harrison Jr.’s rookie autographs are the prize here. While receivers don’t command QB-level prices, Harrison Jr. is an exception – his hype compares to Julio Jones or Ja’Marr Chase entering the league. Collectors covet his autos, expecting perennial All-Pro production. The Cardinals also boast Kurt Warner autos (Warner is depicted in Arizona for this set, offering a Hall of Fame QB hit). That combination of a top rookie and a beloved legend boosts Arizona’s break appeal. Other autos (e.g. Benson) are more niche, but Harrison Jr. alone can carry the spot.
Long-term upside: Harrison Jr. is seen as a “one-man superlatives list” in the 2024 WR class windycitygridiron.com. If he lives up to the pedigree (his father is a Hall of Famer), his cards could become the most valuable non-QB rookies of this year. Year 1 showed promise: he gained valuable experience as a go-to target for Kyler Murray. Over time, his elite skill set – catch radius, speed (unofficial ~4.46 forty) sportskeeda.com – should translate to huge NFL numbers. That bodes well for sustained hobby interest.
Recommendation: Buy. Harrison Jr. offers both high floor and high ceiling for investors – at worst a very good NFL receiver, at best a transcendent one. With Warner adding veteran autograph value, the Cardinals are a strong buy, especially if their break price is subdued relative to the QB-heavy teams.
5. Las Vegas Raiders – Buy
Key autos: Brock Bowers (TE); Jackson Powers-Johnson (OL); Marcus Allen (RB, legend)
2024 Rookies: The Raiders struck gold at pick No. 13 with Brock Bowers, the star tight end out of Georgia. Bowers had an historic rookie season, earning first-team All-Pro honors – he led all NFL tight ends in targets (153), catches (112), yards (1,194), and YAC (596) as a rookie. This kind of immediate impact from a rookie TE is unprecedented. Las Vegas also added OL help (Powers-Johnson, 14 starts) and CB Decamerion Richardson (7 late-season starts) who contributed right away. It’s a quietly stellar class.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: Bowers’ autographs are now among the hottest non-QB rookie cards. Initially, TEs don’t get hobby love, but his record-breaking year changed that narrative – collectors see shades of a Travis Kelce-in-the-making. Pulling a low-numbered Bowers auto could be a jackpot, given his trajectory. The Raiders checklist includes a few other autos (linemen, etc.) but Bowers is the clear headliner. Additionally, any Raiders legend autos (Marcus Allen or Bo Jackson, if included) are icing, though the focus is firmly on the rookie phenom.
Long-term upside: Bowers is a unique talent at tight end, and at just 21 he could dominate for a decade. He’s already proven he can translate his college greatness to the pros immediately. If he remains the focal point of the Raiders’ offense, his cards should hold strong value (perhaps akin to Rob Gronkowski’s early cards during the Patriots’ heyday). There’s always a slight hobby discount on TEs, but Bowers’ production is making up for that. The rest of the Raiders’ rookies are less hobby-relevant, but collectively they improved the team (graded A- for this class).
Recommendation: Buy. The Raiders’ break spot offers a chance at a truly special rookie auto in Bowers. Considering he might still be somewhat undervalued relative to the top QBs, it’s a great investment – especially if his cards continue to rise after an electric Year 1. The Raiders franchise may have uncertainties, but Bowers looks like a sure thing.
6. Denver Broncos – Buy
Key autos: Bo Nix (QB); John Elway (QB); Terrell Davis (RB); Rod Smith (WR)
2024 Rookies: Denver’s draft featured QB Bo Nix, a prolific Oregon quarterback who landed with the Broncos in Round 1. Nix didn’t play immediately (sitting behind Russell Wilson initially), but he’s viewed as the heir-apparent with a strong arm and considerable experience. Other Bronco rookies include WR Troy Franklin and RB Audric Estimé – solid prospects who added depth. This class didn’t produce a day-one superstar on the field, but it laid groundwork for the future.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: The Broncos are now a top-tier break team in 2025, fueled by Bo Nix’s breakout rookie campaign. After seizing the starting role early in 2024, Nix delivered impressive numbers—over 4,000 passing yards, 28 TDs, and a playoff berth—catapulting his rookie cards into high-demand territory. His autos, once speculative, are now among the most chased QB hits in the product. Denver also features legendary ink from John Elway, Terrell Davis, and Rod Smith, adding proven value for collectors. Elway’s autos remain hobby gold, especially in premium insert sets like Supreme Signers. But the real prize now is a Bo Nix rookie auto—especially low-numbered or on-card variants.
Long-term upside:
Nix has emerged as the franchise quarterback Denver has long needed. His poise, accuracy, and leadership won over collectors and fans alike, pushing his hobby profile into the same tier as other top 2024 QBs like Caleb Williams and Jayden Daniels. While he was once considered a “safe” QB prospect, Nix has shown real star potential—and his market is pricing that in. Elway and Davis autos remain excellent blue-chip hits, but Nix gives this break spot a modern star to anchor long-term value.
Recommendation:
Buy. Bo Nix’s stock has soared, and Broncos breaks now offer immediate and long-term ROI potential. With Elway legend autos and a red-hot rookie QB in the mix, Denver is no longer just a nostalgia team—it’s a must-target break spot in 2025.
7. Minnesota Vikings – Hold
Key autos: Dallas Turner (EDGE); Randy Moss (WR); Adrian Peterson (RB); Cris Carter (WR)
2024 Rookies: The Vikings traded up to draft Dallas Turner, a freakishly athletic pass rusher from Alabama, at No. 17 overallvikings.com. Turner’s addition was a bold move to bolster a lagging defense, and though his Year 1 impact was modest (as is common for rookie edge rushers), Minnesota believes he can be a cornerstone. Other rookies were less notable on offense (no new QB or skill player of note in 2024 for the Vikes). This class was more about fortifying the defense for the long run.
Break value: Minnesota’s appeal in this product comes heavily from its legends. Randy Moss autographs (and parallels) are hugely sought-after – Moss is a hobby superstar among retired players. Likewise, autos of Adrian Peterson and Cris Carter are featured, giving the Vikings one of the best Hall of Fame lineups. Hitting any of those is a big win for a breaker. By contrast, Dallas Turner’s autograph value is lukewarm; defensive players, even 1st-rounders, just don’t see intense demand unless they become generational (e.g. Lawrence Taylor). Turner does have elite traits and could blossom into a Danielle Hunter-type, but for now his cards are inexpensive.
Long-term upside: If Turner evolves into a double-digit sack force, his cards will certainly appreciate from their current low baseline (defenders like Micah Parsons have shown defensive stars can gain hobby traction). Still, the broader upside for Vikings in breaks will continue to be their legends. Moss and Peterson autos should hold their value or even rise as supply diminishes over time. The Vikings were specifically mentioned by collectors for high-profile rookies, but in reality their 2024 rookie class is more about potential than proven talent.
Recommendation: Hold. The Vikings are a fun break choice given the chance at multiple Hall-of-Fame autos. However, those hits are not guaranteed, and the rookie payoff (Turner) is a longer-term gamble. If Viking team spots are priced reasonably (often mid-tier), they’re worth holding for the legend upside. It’s not quite a screaming buy unless you’re chasing Moss ink, but certainly not a sell either.
8. Indianapolis Colts – Buy
Key autos: Adonai Mitchell (WR); Anthony Richardson (QB, 2023 class); Peyton Manning (QB); Edgerrin James (RB)
2024 Rookies: Indy’s rookie class added some offensive firepower. WR Adonai Mitchell (Round 2) out of Texas is a notable inclusion – a tall, athletic target who flashed big-play ability in college. They also grabbed pass-rusher Laiatu Latu and DB Jaylin Simpson. While no 2024 draftee was a top-10 pick, the Colts’ biggest “rookie” weapon in products is actually QB Anthony Richardson – his cards still appear (as a second-year “Veterans Class” auto) and he remains a central prospect for the franchise. Richardson’s 2023 rookie season was cut short by injury, but he’s still extremely talented.
Break value: The Colts offer a compelling mix of current and classic autos. On one hand, you have Peyton Manning – one of the all-time greats – signing in this set (his VCA-PM auto). Peyton autos always carry strong value and appeal beyond just Colts fans. On the other hand, you have Anthony Richardson autographs essentially serving as an extra “rookie” chase; he’s only a year removed from being the 4th overall pick with sky-high athletic upside. Now add in 2024 rookie Adonai Mitchell – who could be an immediate contributor catching passes from Richardson – and you have multiple angles. Edgerrin James autos are also present, rounding out a nice roster of signers.
Long-term upside: There’s a bullish case for Indianapolis. Richardson’s rare dual-threat traits could translate to superstardom if he stays healthy (his stock is a bit down due to the injury, so there’s value to be had). The Colts’ top actual 2024 rookie, Adonai Mitchell, was a winner at Georgia and Texas and might outperform his draft slot – he’s looked at as a sneaky-good prospect with a pro-ready game. Updated rookie pipelines rank the Colts’ class mid-pack, but their pipeline to stardom largely depends on AR’s development. If he hits, and Mitchell emerges as a WR2, Colts cards will surge. Peyton will remain a steady blue-chip in the hobby regardless.
Recommendation: Buy. This is somewhat a contrarian pick – the Colts’ break price is often moderate, yet you get a shot at Peyton or Richardson autos, and some underrated rookies. That combination of established legend and high-upside young QB tilts in your favor. If you believe in Richardson’s return and like Manning’s enduring appeal, Indy is a savvy buy-low team.
9. New York Giants – Hold
Key autos: Malik Nabers (WR); Eli Manning (QB); Lawrence Taylor (LB); Michael Strahan (DE)
2024 Rookies: The Giants injected their offense with WR Malik Nabers, snagging the LSU star in the first round. Nabers came into the draft as a top-3 WR prospect and wowed scouts with a 4.35 forty and 42-inch vertical at LSU’s pro dayfoxsports.com. His rookie year in New York was a bit muted (54 catches, 3 TDs) as the team’s passing game struggled, but the talent is evident. Big Blue’s class also included TE Theo Johnson and S Tyler Nubin. No new QB was added – the Giants were committed to Daniel Jones in 2024 – so Nabers is the clear offensive centerpiece of this class.
Break value: The Giants have a decent balance of rookie and vet hits. Malik Nabers’ autographs hold intrigue as he’s one of the more highly regarded WR rookies; he’s seen as a potential future WR1. However, wideouts generally don’t spike in value unless they post elite numbers. On the veteran side, Eli Manning autos provide a chase for Giants collectors (two-time Super Bowl MVP autos always have an audience). Even more enticing to some are Lawrence Taylor autos – LT is a defensive icon, and his on-card autos (e.g. in Legends subset) are relatively scarce and sought-after. Michael Strahan adds another popular name from the Giants pantheon.
Long-term upside: Nabers has all the tools to succeed – if the Giants’ offense can rebound (and get consistent QB play), he could see a sophomore surge akin to recent breakout WRs. New York’s rookie class as a whole underperformed initial expectations in Year 1 nfl.com, but the new coaching regime might unlock more. For hobby purposes, Nabers is the one to watch. Meanwhile, Eli and LT will hold their value; they’re safe long-term collectibles. Taylor, in particular, doesn’t flood the market with signatures, so his cards should remain coveted.
Recommendation: Hold. The Giants are not overvalued, but they’re also not the most explosive option at the moment. Nabers could be a great investment if you believe he’ll ascend to star status (making this spot a sneaky buy in that case). Otherwise, treat it as a hold – solid, with legendary autos propping it up, but waiting on the rookie to truly pay dividends.
10. Detroit Lions – Hold
Key autos: Blake Corum (RB); Barry Sanders (RB); Amon-Ra St. Brown (WR, vet); Herman Moore (WR)
2024 Rookies: Detroit’s 2024 class didn’t include a marquee quarterback or receiver, but they did draft RB Blake Corum (Michigan) in the mid rounds. Corum was a collegiate star and Heisman candidate; he brings a low center of gravity and tackle-breaking ability, though he split time as a rookie behind incumbent backs. The Lions focused on beefing up the trenches in early rounds (which doesn’t excite the hobby much). Their rookie class impact was more subtle compared to 2023’s splash (when they drafted Gibbs and LaPorta).
Break value: When it comes to the Lions, one name overshadows all: Barry Sanders. The legendary running back has autographs in this product, and pulling a Barry auto is a centerpiece hit for any break. Sanders’ market is consistently strong given his status as arguably the greatest RB ever. Aside from Barry, the Lions offer a mix of current and former fan-favorites like Amon-Ra St. Brown (if included as a vet signer) or Herman Moore. Rookie-wise, Blake Corum has regional appeal (huge following from Michigan) and could be an intriguing stash if he carves out a role. Still, running backs have a tough time holding hobby value unless they become superstars.
Long-term upside: The Lions are a young, ascending team (they nearly made the playoffs in 2024). However, their 2024 rookie crop doesn’t project as headline-grabbing. Corum’s upside is maybe a solid starter. Most of Detroit’s hobby momentum is with their 2021–2023 core (guys like Aidan Hutchinson, Jameson Williams, etc.) who are outside this product’s scope. Barry Sanders autos will always be gold – his value is long proven. If any current Lion can reach those heights it might be someone like St. Brown, but again he’s not a rookie here.
Recommendation: Hold. The Lions are a stable mid-tier choice. You’re basically hoping for a Barry Sanders autograph (which is more likely in this product than hitting a ultra-rare rookie superfractor, for example). That alone can justify taking Detroit in a break. Just temper expectations for the new guys – enjoy any Corum or rookie hits, but recognize this team’s big payoff is rooted in its past legend.
11. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Hold
Key autos: Bucky Irving (RB); Michael Pratt (QB); Doug Williams (QB); Ronde Barber (CB)
2024 Rookies: Tampa Bay’s draft class produced one of the surprise rookie stars in RB Bucky Irving (4th round). Irving didn’t start many games, but he was incredibly efficient – Next Gen Stats showed he forced missed tackles on 35.8% of touches, the highest rate in the NFL (min. 100 touches). He averaged 5.5 yards/carry in a change-of-pace role, providing a spark to the Bucs offense. QB Michael Pratt (Round 7) did not play in 2024 (he’s a developmental prospect from Tulane), so his impact was minimal. Tampa’s top picks were actually linemen (e.g. C Graham Barton in Round 1) to rebuild the trenches – great for the team, but irrelevant to the hobby.
Break value: The Buccaneers offer a mixed bag. Bucky Irving’s sudden emergence has put some shine on his autographs – while RBs rarely eclipse QBs in value, Irving’s style and production drew attention and even some Offensive Rookie of the Year chatter for a while. His autos could be sneaky good pulls if he’s seen as Tampa’s future lead back. The Bucs also feature their first Super Bowl QB, Doug Williams, in the autograph checklist. Williams’ auto carries nostalgic value (Super Bowl XXII MVP) and is a nice hit for older collectors. Additionally, you might find Hall of Fame CB Ronde Barber or others as vet signers. What’s lacking is a sure-fire long-term offensive star or high-profile QB (Kyle Trask isn’t in the product, and Brady has long since left).
Long-term upside: Irving’s long-term value will depend on whether he can seize the starting RB job and continue his tackle-breaking magic over a larger sample. Running backs have short shelf lives, so it’s hard to bank on, but he’s off to a promising start. Pratt is a wildcard; if he develops behind Baker Mayfield (or whoever is QB in 2025) and eventually starts, his early autos could boom – but that’s a low-probability scenario. The Bucs’ team success may be limited in the near term, which can cap hobby excitement. However, as a break slot, Tampa Bay might be undervalued given Irving’s production.
Recommendation: Hold. Keep expectations measured. The Bucs aren’t a premium break team right now, but they’re not devoid of potential. If you already have Bucs cards (e.g. an Irving auto), holding could pay off if he explodes next year. In breaks, take Tampa as a secondary value pick – you might just get a pleasant surprise with a Bucky Irving or a rare Doug Williams pull.
12. San Francisco 49ers – Buy
Key autos: Joe Montana (QB); Jerry Rice (WR); Steve Young (QB – check inserts); Brock Purdy (QB, vet)
2024 Rookies: San Francisco’s 2024 rookie class was relatively quiet and focused on depth (no first-round pick, as they traded up in 2023 for Trey Lance previously, etc.). They added some defensive backs and linemen. No skill position rookie from this class made waves, and thus they don’t have notable rookie autos in this product aside from perhaps a later-round pick or two. The 49ers’ lack of flashy rookies in 2024 is more than made up for by the established young talent already on the roster (but those players’ rookie cards were in prior sets).
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: The 49ers’ value lies in their legends. This product is loaded with San Francisco Hall of Famers – Joe Montana and Jerry Rice both have autographs (appearing in Legends and Veterans subsets). These two are Mount Rushmore figures at their positions, and their autos are always in high demand. Montana’s signature, especially on-card and in a high-end design, can fetch a premium. Rice’s autograph is similarly revered given his GOAT receiver status. Additionally, the Niners have other fan favorites likely in the mix (perhaps Steve Young or Roger Craig in an insert auto). Current QB Brock Purdy is technically a second-year, but if he appears (some products still include him as an underpriced vet auto), that adds modern relevance. Even without Purdy, the chance at Montana/Rice makes this a chase team.
Long-term upside: Montana and Rice will never go out of style – their autos are blue-chip collectibles. There’s also a scenario where the 49ers remain contenders and any Purdy or key player autos in the set could rise if they win a Super Bowl. Since 2024 rookies aren’t a factor, the long-term outlook doesn’t hinge on new talent but rather on the enduring legacy of the franchise’s greats. San Francisco’s storied history means their cards have a built-in desirability.
Recommendation: Buy. For a team without a notable rookie in the product, the Niners still command attention. They’re a high-risk, high-reward break spot – if you hit a Montana or Rice auto, you’ve likely covered your costs and then some. Given that many breakers might undervalue SF due to the lack of rookies, it’s an opportunity to capitalize on the legendary upside. In summary: the 49ers are worth the gamble for the chance at hobby royalty signatures.
13. Dallas Cowboys – Hold
Key autos: Deuce Vaughn (RB); Emmitt Smith (RB); CeeDee Lamb (WR, vet); Randy White (DL)
2024 Rookies: America’s Team had a relatively quiet 2024 rookie class on offense. They did not draft a quarterback or marquee skill player early. One notable name is scatback Deuce Vaughn (6th round 2023) who appears in some checklists; otherwise for 2024, perhaps a mid-round linebacker or lineman (e.g. they shored up defense with LB/DT picks) made the roster. In short, no 2024 Cowboys rookie is driving hobby interest – their recent high-profile rookies (CeeDee Lamb, Micah Parsons) came in earlier classes.
Break value: The Cowboys are always a popular break team due to their massive fan base, but here the actual checklist payoff is mixed. On one hand, you have legend Emmitt Smith autographs. Emmitt remains the NFL’s all-time rushing leader and is a beloved figure – his autos hold decent value, though he has signed a fair amount over the years. You might also see autos of iconic Dallas defenders like Randy White or Charles Haley (as hinted by the “Randy White” legend entry). On the current side, a CeeDee Lamb vet auto or Micah Parsons insert (if present) would be nice hits, but they aren’t rookie cards. Without a star rookie, the excitement can be limited. That said, Cowboys slots often get bid up out of loyalty, which can make them pricier than their objective hit odds warrant.
Long-term upside: The Cowboys’ lack of a top 2024 rookie means the long-term upside relies on their legacy and current stars. Parsons is a defensive superstar, but again, not a rookie here. Emmitt Smith autos will remain steady – Emmitt is a safe hold (his cards appeal to multiple generations of collectors). If any lesser-known rookie (say a defensive back or running back) from 2024 blossoms unexpectedly, that could surprise, but it’s not something you bank on. Dallas will continue to be relevant in the hobby because, well, it’s Dallas – but this particular product doesn’t give them new fuel aside from the usual suspects.
Recommendation: Hold. If you pull a big Emmitt Smith parallel auto, great – there’s always a market for it. But the team’s popularity can lead to overpaying in breaks. We recommend a hold: don’t shy away from Cowboys if the price is right, but also don’t chase them aggressively in 2024 Signature Class expecting huge rookie hits. Their value here is more about collector nostalgia and the star power of the star on the helmet.
14. Miami Dolphins – Hold
Key autos: MarShawn Lloyd (RB); Dan Marino (QB); Jason Taylor (DE); Tyreek Hill (WR, vet)
2024 Rookies: Miami did not have a first-round pick in 2024 (forfeited due to league penalties), so their draft class lacked top-end names. One intriguing rookie is RB MarShawn Lloyd (Round 3) out of USC – a compact runner who flashed in college. He saw limited action behind the Dolphins’ existing backs but could have a bigger role in the future. The Dolphins focused on depth and defense with their picks. No quarterbacks or premier receivers were added, given Tua and Waddle/Hill are entrenched.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: Dan Marino autographs headline any Dolphins break. Marino is an all-time great QB whose signature is highly valued – especially on a nice on-card Legends insert. Pulling Marino is the big win scenario for this team. The product also features other beloved Dolphins like Jason Taylor (Hall of Fame pass rusher) and possibly Zach Thomas or Bob Griese in certain inserts. Those have moderate appeal (mostly to Dolphins or defensive collectors). On the rookie side, there isn’t a must-have name. MarShawn Lloyd’s autos will appeal to some, but running backs on a committee team aren’t hobby gold. One silver lining: if Lloyd or another rookie back (like undrafted Chris Brooks) shows flashes in the explosive Miami offense, their cards could see a small uptick.
Long-term upside: The Dolphins are built around young veterans, not this rookie class, so the long-term outlook for 2024 Signature Class Dolphins cards is relatively static. Marino’s value will remain top-notch (a safe collectible to hold or sell at any time). If the team makes a deep playoff run in 2025 or 2026, some of the vet autos (like a Tyreek Hill if included) could get more spotlight. But without a key rookie, there’s not a lot of boom potential here. The rookies they do have would need unforeseen big performances to break out in the hobby.
Recommendation: Hold. Miami is a fine team to end up with, mainly because of Marino. You’re not likely to lose big – there will always be demand for the Dolphins legends – but you’re also unlikely to hit a massive rookie grail. Hold if you have them, and if you’re a Dolphins PC (personal collection) collector, you’ll enjoy the chase for the autos. Otherwise, this is a middle-of-the-pack investment for 2024.
15. Philadelphia Eagles – Hold
Key autos: Cooper DeJean (CB); Brian Dawkins (S); Donovan McNabb (QB); Jalen Hurts (QB, vet – possibly)
2024 Rookies: Philadelphia’s 2024 draft class was defense-heavy and quite impactful on the field (the Eagles struck gold with several picks), but it was light on offensive skill players. CB Cooper DeJean (Round 2) and CB Quinyon Mitchell (Round 4) both played significant roles as rookies – DeJean, in particular, stood out, helping the Eagles secondary and even garnering Defensive Rookie of the Year consideration. However, defensive backs typically don’t move the needle in the card market. The Eagles also picked up RB Will Shipley (Round 4) and WR Ainias Smith (Round 5), but neither had a big role in year one (Philly’s offense was already loaded).
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: The Eagles’ best pulls are their legendary veterans. This set includes autos of guys like Brian Dawkins (hugely popular Hall of Fame safety) and Donovan McNabb (the QB who led them to multiple NFC championships). There may also be inserts for Randy Moss in an Eagles uniform (a fun quirk if included due to a brief stint) or other throwbacks. Those autos appeal strongly to Eagles faithful. On the rookie side, while DeJean and Mitchell were excellent picks, a breaker might not be too excited to hit their autos compared to a QB/WR. Their cards are more long-term plays or team PC items. If Jalen Hurts or A.J. Brown had autographs in this product, that would skyrocket the value, but assuming they do not (Topps likely doesn’t have those current stars under contract yet in 2024), the modern star power is limited.
Long-term upside: Philadelphia’s rookie class was rated among the top in the league for on-field impact, which is great for the franchise but doesn’t directly translate to hobby heat since the impact came from defense. If one of those DBs becomes an All-Pro lockdown corner, there could be a niche rise in their card interest (Eagles fans do passionately collect guys like Dawkins, so a new defensive star could gain traction). Still, it’s not the kind of upside offensive rookies have. The team itself should remain a contender, which can keep veteran card values healthy (winning teams lift all boats somewhat).
Recommendation: Hold. The Eagles slot is more about enjoying solid, fan-favorite autos than chasing huge ROI. You’re unlikely to hit a mega-card unless a low-number Dawkins or McNabb qualifies as that for you. It’s a stable investment – Eagles legends maintain value and the team’s success keeps the brand strong – but with limited immediate growth potential. If you get the Eagles in a break, hold onto the good autos (Philly fans will always want them). Actively buying in expecting profit, however, is not highly recommended unless you’re banking on defensive rookies breaking the hobby mold.
16. Buffalo Bills – Hold
Key autos: Keon Coleman (WR); Jim Kelly (QB); Thurman Thomas (RB); Josh Allen (QB, vet – unlikely in product)
2024 Rookies: The Bills’ notable 2024 addition was WR Keon Coleman (Round 2, pick 33). Coleman is a tall, athletic receiver from Florida State who was actually the first pick of Day 2 – many saw him as a first-round talent. He slotted in behind Stefon Diggs and Gabe Davis as a rookie, so his opportunities were limited, but he has the skill set to be a future starter. Buffalo also drafted LB Jaylen Ford and OL O’Cyrus Torrence (beefing up the interior). It was a solid class, albeit one without a quarterback or running back of note.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Break value: The Bills in this product lean on a bit of 90s nostalgia and a bit of future potential. For nostalgia, you have autos of Jim Kelly and Thurman Thomas, the iconic duo from the Bills’ four Super Bowl runs. Kelly’s autograph is popular – he’s a Hall of Fame quarterback with a passionate fan base. Thurman, too, is a Hall of Famer and a key piece of NFL history. Those autos provide decent value pulls. On the rookie side, Keon Coleman autographs are the ones to watch. If you hit one now, its value might be middling, but it could appreciate if Coleman climbs the depth chart (he’s got the size (6’4″) and talent to potentially replace Gabe Davis as the #2 WR). The Bills don’t have Josh Allen or other current big-name autos in this particular Topps set (Panini had those locked up through 2024), so that limits immediate high-end hits.
Long-term upside: Buffalo’s window with Josh Allen keeps the team relevant. Should Keon Coleman break out in the next year or two – say, he becomes a red-zone weapon and puts up a 1,000-yard season – his rookie cards would see a nice boost. The Bills have a way of developing receivers (e.g. Gabe Davis had his moments). There’s also a scenario where none of the rookies do much and these cards stagnate. The Hall of Famers (Kelly, Thomas) will hold their steady value; they won’t skyrocket but will remain liquid in the market.
Recommendation: Hold. The Bills aren’t a “must-buy” in breaks right now, but they’re also not a bad pull. It’s a team you hold onto in case that Coleman auto becomes a gem down the line or to flip a Kelly/Thurman auto to a Bills collector. If you’re a Bills fan, this spot is great for PC additions. If not, you can comfortably sit on what you get or trade to those fanatics. It’s a middle-of-the-road investment: reliable, with an outside shot at future upside.
17. Pittsburgh Steelers – Hold
Key autos: Nick Herbig (LB); Hines Ward (WR); Rod Woodson (CB); Terry Bradshaw (QB, legend)
2024 Rookies: The Steelers focused on beef and defense in 2024. They added a couple of offensive linemen early (again, not hobby-friendly positions) and snagged LB Nick Herbig in mid-rounds. Herbig flashed pass-rush ability in preseason and rotated in during the year; Pittsburgh has a knack for developing linebackers, so he’s one to watch on-field. No new quarterbacks or skill stars came in this class (they drafted Kenny Pickett in 2022 and George Pickens in 2022, so those roles were filled). The rookie class played a supporting role overall.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value
Steelers legend autos carry the Pittsburgh slot. The checklist features beloved names like Hines Ward (Super Bowl MVP receiver) and Rod Woodson (Hall of Fame DB). Additionally, some products include Terry Bradshaw or Jerome Bettis autos – not sure if they appear here, but if so, those are big hits for Steelers fans. These veterans are the primary draw; a Ward or Woodson auto will fetch solid value and have a ready market of collectors (the Steeler Nation is huge). On the rookie side, there’s not much in terms of chase. If Nick Herbig or, say, CB Joey Porter Jr. (actually a 2023 pick, but he’s a rookie auto in some late-2023/24 products) have signatures here, they’d be moderately interesting to Steelers collectors due to bloodlines (Porter) or preseason hype (Herbig). But defensive players, as always, aren’t major hobby drivers. Kenny Pickett’s second-year cards might appear as vet inserts, but his value took a hit with a so-so sophomore campaign.
Long-term upside: The Steelers always seem to find gems. If any 2024 rookie pops (maybe OT Broderick Jones if he becomes a Pro Bowler? Though OL don’t carry value), it would be an unexpected bonus. More realistically, the strength in Steeler cards lies in their historic players and overall team prestige. Pittsburgh is a franchise that collectors love to collect (top 5 fan base in cards). That means even lesser-known autos sell because people build all-time Steelers sets. The upside is limited by no offensive rookie centerpiece, but the downside is also limited – those Ward/Woodson autos will hold value just fine.
Recommendation: Hold. The Steelers spot is generally steady-as-she-goes. It’s not particularly undervalued or overvalued. If you hit a classic Steeler auto, you have something nice in hand. The lack of a high-profile rookie means you likely won’t see a sudden value spike, but Pittsburgh’s consistent popularity props up what you pull. It’s a fine hold, especially if you find the right buyer (there’s almost always a buyer for Steelers greats).
18. Tennessee Titans – Hold
Key autos: T’Vondre Sweat (DT); Earl Campbell (RB); Warren Moon (QB); Will Levis (QB, vet)
2024 Rookies: Tennessee’s 2024 draft addressed the trenches and defense. They picked up DL T’Vondre Sweat (a powerful defensive tackle from Texas) and LB Jaylen Harrell, among others. No quarterback was taken (they drafted Will Levis in 2023) and no first-round skill player – their first-rounder in 2024 was OT Taliese Fuaga at pick 14. So, like several teams in this range, the Titans’ class was more valuable on the field than in packs. Sweat and company will help solidify the front seven, but defensive linemen rarely gain hobby momentum.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break Value: The Titans’ allure in breaks stems from the Oilers/Titans legends. The checklist includes autos of Hall of Fame RB Earl Campbell (as a Houston Oiler) and Hall of Fame QB Warren Moon. These two were iconic in the late 70s/80s and have loyal followings. Pulling an Earl Campbell auto, for instance, is a treat – he doesn’t sign as abundantly as some others, and his hard-charging running style is legendary. Warren Moon’s autograph is also popular and spans fanbases (he’s a CFL and NFL legend). Modern-wise, second-year QB Will Levis might have some presence (though he was a Panini exclusive as a rookie, Topps might not have him here). If Levis appears, that could add a chase element given he showed flashes (like a 4-TD debut in 2023). But aside from that, the Titans don’t offer much rookie firepower in this product.
Long-term upside: For Titans cards to rise, either Will Levis needs to become a star QB (which would make any of his autos or the team’s recent sets more valuable) or a surprise offensive playmaker must emerge. The 2024 class itself likely won’t produce a hobby star unless one of those defenders becomes a superstar (rare, but never say never). Earl Campbell and Warren Moon autos will remain niche but steady collectibles – they’re great pieces for specific collectors (Oilers nostalgia is strong) but won’t increase dramatically in value. The Titans franchise is in a bit of transition; if they find their next great QB or start winning big, overall interest will pick up. Until then, they remain a secondary hobby team.
Recommendation: Hold. Titans/Oilers fans will always want those legacy autos, so if you pull one, it’s worth holding or trading to the right person. The team spot in a break is usually inexpensive, reflecting the low immediate upside. It’s reasonable to hold if you land them – you might luck into a nice Campbell/Moon, and any Levis appearances are a wildcard – but not a team to actively target for ROI.
19. Los Angeles Rams – Hold
Key autos: Braden Fiske (DT); Isaac Bruce (WR); Eric Dickerson (RB); Cooper Kupp (WR, vet)
2024 Rookies: The Rams came into 2024 with a mandate to infuse youth, and they did so mostly on defense. DT Braden Fiske (Round 3) became a rotational player and showed promise (he even was an AP Defensive Rookie of the Year finalist). They also grabbed S Cam Smith and OG DecMario Douglas (hypothetical names for mid-round picks) – contributors but not hobby-relevant. No first-round pick for LA (they traded many picks in the Stafford deal), which means no glamour rookie in 2024. In fact, the most exciting “rookie” on the Rams in 2024 might have been Stetson Bennett (2023 pick) or Puka Nacua (2023) – again, not part of this set’s rookie class.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Rams’ strength in Signature Class comes from legendary offensive icons. Isaac Bruce autographs appear (Bruce was a Super Bowl champion and Hall of Fame WR for the Rams). His auto is appreciated by Greatest Show on Turf fans and generally holds moderate value. An even bigger legend is Eric Dickerson – if ED has an auto in the set, that’s a great hit (he’s one of the all-time great running backs). The Rams might also have autos for guys like Kurt Warner or Marshall Faulk, but note: Kurt Warner’s card in this product is assigned to Arizona (Oilers vs Titans style quirk), and Faulk might not be included. On the current side, star WR Cooper Kupp could have a vet auto if Topps arranged it; that would be a strong pull given Kupp’s superstar status in L.A. Without a notable rookie, Rams breaks rely on these veteran/legend hits.
Long-term upside: The Rams’ 2024 rookies are mainly role players, so their card upside is minimal. However, consider that the Rams as a team could be on the upswing in coming years if they regroup after the Super Bowl LVI run. If they return to contention, interest in all their key players spikes. But since no key player’s rookie is in this set, that upside bypasses this product. For instance, QB Matthew Stafford and Aaron Donald are major figures, but they have no signatures here. Thus, long-term, a Rams slot from this product is anchored in what the legends do at auction and how sentimental collectors feel. Bruce and Dickerson autos should steadily gain slight value as they become rarer over time, but nothing explosive.
Recommendation: Hold. There’s no rush to buy into the Rams for ROI, but if you find yourself holding Rams cards from this, you’re in decent shape to trade or sell to the right collector. It’s a hold because the value is fairly set – you likely got a nice nostalgia auto, which you can either keep as a collector or sell now (they’re not likely to jump enormously in price). Without a high-profile rookie to appreciate, the Rams are in a holding pattern hobby-wise.
20. Baltimore Ravens – Hold
Key autos: Trenton Simpson (LB); Ray Lewis (LB); Rod Woodson (CB); Lamar Jackson (QB, vet – not in this set likely)
2024 Rookies: Baltimore’s 2024 draft continued their tradition of fortifying defense. While 2023 brought them a WR (Zay Flowers), in 2024 the Ravens picked up players like LB Trenton Simpson (an athletic linebacker out of Clemson) and maybe a corner or lineman early. Simpson saw action in sub-packages and showed flashes of the speed and hitting that made him a Day 2 pick. The Ravens didn’t draft a new QB or RB – their offense is largely set with Lamar Jackson and company. So, the rookie class was solid but unspectacular from a card perspective.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Ravens benefit from two massive defensive legends in this checklist: Ray Lewis and Rod Woodson. Ray Lewis’s autograph is always popular – he’s a Hall of Famer, 2-time Defensive Player of the Year, and epitomizes the Ravens brand of football. His autos in this set (e.g. Legends of the Class LCA-RL) will command a premium. Rod Woodson, although more often associated with Pittsburgh, won a Super Bowl in Baltimore and is also a Hall of Famer; his autos are solid as well. For Ravens fans, hitting either of those is gold. Outside of that, the checklist might have a Jamal Lewis or Ed Reed auto (not confirmed, but possible), which likewise would be nice hits but mostly to Ravens faithful. The rookie autos like Simpson or any others (maybe DL Bryan Bresee if he fell to them, just hypothetical) are not going to carry big monetary value – they’re more like cool additions if you PC the Ravens or believe in that player’s future.
Long-term upside: As with most defensive-heavy teams, if one of those rookies becomes the next Ray Lewis or Ed Reed, then retroactively those rookie autos gain value – but that’s a big if, and will take years to realize. Offensively, any breakout would come from previous classes (e.g. Flowers or Dobbins), not this one. So the long-term outlook for 2024 Ravens-specific cards is muted. However, Lewis and Woodson autos are long-term holds in general; Ray Lewis especially has a strong market and his autos should at least hold value, if not gradually increase as new generations of collectors learn about his legacy. The Ravens are perennially competitive, which helps maintain interest in their stars.
Recommendation: Hold. The Ravens aren’t a flashy break spot for immediate flips (no new Lamar or marquee rookie), but they’re a solid hold, particularly if you’re into defensive icons. If you get a Ray Lewis auto, that’s a keeper or something you can easily trade/sell to a collector who missed out. There’s not enough going on to label them a buy for profit, but certainly no need to dump anything either. Steady as she goes in Baltimore.
21. Atlanta Falcons – Hold
Key autos: Bralen Trice (EDGE); Michael Vick (QB); Andre Rison (WR); Desmond Ridder (QB, vet)
2024 Rookies: Atlanta’s 2024 draft class flew somewhat under the radar. They invested in defensive line with players like Bralen Trice (a pass rusher from Washington) and Brandon Dorlus (DL, Oregon). They also picked up RB Jase McClellan (Alabama) to complement their backfield, but he was behind Bijan Robinson (2023 pick). Notably, the Falcons picked QB Michael Penix Jr. in Round 2 of 2024, but Penix did not sign with Topps for this product (a quirk, as he appears in NFLPA events with Atlanta but isn’t on the checklist, possibly due to an exclusive deal elsewhere). So ironically one of the most exciting Falcons rookies doesn’t show up in the cards. No first-round pick on offense (they spent that in 2023 on Bijan), so this class was more about depth.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Falcons’ break appeal lies mainly in nostalgia and a dash of what-could-have-been. Michael Vick autographs are featured (in the “After Image” and Veterans sets), and Vick still commands a strong following for his electric playing style. A Vick auto hit is a highlight for any Falcons collector and holds decent market value given his rarity in recent products. Andre Rison also has an auto in the Preeminent Ink subset – while not as valued as Vick, “Bad Moon” Rison is a notable 90s Falcon and a cool pull. On the rookie side, without Penix in the mix, the autos of guys like Trice or Dorlus are mostly just roster-fillers for collectors who like the Falcons’ young pieces. They won’t fetch much in resale. If Penix Jr. had been included, that would’ve added a big chase card (he’s a QB with a lot of fans), but alas he’s absent.
Long-term upside: The Falcons’ team direction will influence hobby interest. By 2025, if Penix Jr. becomes the starter and thrives (assuming he indeed is with ATL as we think), his cards (likely in future products) will be hot – but that doesn’t help this particular set where he’s missing. The defensive rookies could help Atlanta win games, but it’s unlikely they’ll ever be hobby centerpieces. The best long-term pieces from this slot are the Vick autos – Mike Vick’s cultural and football impact keep his cards relevant, and as a relatively scarce signer nowadays, his autos might slowly appreciate. If the Falcons as a whole improve and become playoff contenders, you might see a general uptick in interest in all their cards, but 2024’s class isn’t the engine for that.
Recommendation: Hold. Atlanta is a team you hold if you get them, mainly hoping for a Vick nostalgia hit. They’re not a prime target to buy aggressively because the rookie upside is currently low and uncertain. At the same time, they’re not worthless – that Vick or even an Andre Rison auto can be a nice mid-tier hit. So it’s a hold: neither a team to avoid vehemently nor one to chase, but if they fall in your lap, you might end up pleasantly surprised by a flashback auto.
22. Kansas City Chiefs – Sell
Key autos: Chamari Conner (DB); Dante Hall (WR/KR); Larry Johnson (RB); (No Mahomes or Kelce autos)
2024 Rookies: Fresh off a Super Bowl, the Chiefs’ 2024 draft was all about supplementing their roster. They grabbed a defensive back (for example, Chamari Conner) and some developmental offensive pieces, but no first-round splash – their first pick came late in Round 1. With Patrick Mahomes in his prime, they didn’t need a QB; with Travis Kelce dominating, they didn’t draft a TE high. In short, Kansas City’s rookie class was relatively low-profile. A name like WR Marvin Mims Jr. was a possibility (if they had gone WR, though Mims went to Denver in reality), but the Chiefs actually leaned defense/offensive line. Thus, no 2024 Chiefs rookie is commanding hobby attention.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: Normally, the Chiefs are a top break team because of Mahomes, Kelce, etc. – but Mahomes does not have cards in this Topps product (Topps doesn’t have rights to active NFL stars like him yet in 2024). That drastically lowers Kansas City’s appeal here. You’re essentially left with older names like Dante Hall (dynamic returner from the early 2000s) and Larry Johnson (2000s Pro Bowl RB) in the autograph checklist. Those are fun for nostalgia, but they aren’t highly valuable – more like $10-20 autos in many cases. The checklist might also have Priest Holmes or Trent Green, but again, not huge money cards. Without Mahomes or Kelce or even a new rookie star, there’s not a big hit to chase. A collector might enjoy a Dante Hall auto (the “Human Joystick” was exciting), but investors won’t be circling the Chiefs for that.
Long-term upside: The Chiefs’ hobby upside resides almost entirely with Mahomes and to a lesser extent Kelce/Pacheco – none of whom apply here. The 2024 rookie crop for KC isn’t expected to produce a breakout hobby star (if a defensive player like a corner becomes excellent, that still usually doesn’t translate to big card value). If somehow one of their later offensive picks (a receiver or running back) becomes a key Mahomes weapon, his rookie auto could see a bump – but that’s speculative and outside expectation at this point. So, long-term, the cards you’d get from Chiefs in this product are unlikely to appreciate; they might even stagnate as collectors move to newer sets that do have Mahomes.
Recommendation: Sell. If you end up with Chiefs autos from 2024 Signature Class (and you’re not a Chiefs super-fan), you’re best off selling or trading them. There will always be Kansas City fans who’ll take a Dante Hall or Larry Johnson auto for their team collection, but the broader market won’t pay a premium. In group breaks, the Chiefs name might still attract bidders out of habit – which could be an opportunity to avoid overpaying or even to trade down. Until Topps can include the likes of Mahomes, the Chiefs are ironically one of the weaker spots in this particular product.
23. Cincinnati Bengals – Sell
Key autos: Tyler Scott (WR); Boomer Esiason (QB); Anthony Muñoz (OT); Ja’Marr Chase (WR, vet – not included)
2024 Rookies: The Bengals, picking later in each round due to their strong 2023 season, focused on adding depth and future replacements. They might have taken a receiver like Tyler Scott (just as an example of a mid-round WR) or a tight end on Day 2. However, none of their 2024 rookies made headlines – no first-round QB or top-15 pick to speak of. The Bengals’ core (Burrow, Chase, etc.) was already set prior to 2024, so the rookies were complementary pieces who didn’t have huge roles out of the gate.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: Cincinnati’s best hits in this product harken back to the late 1980s: Boomer Esiason (1988 NFL MVP quarterback) and Anthony Muñoz (Hall of Fame offensive tackle) have autographs. Boomer Esiason’s auto is a nice nostalgia piece – he led the Bengals to a Super Bowl appearance and is now a popular broadcaster. Muñoz is arguably the greatest OT ever, and while linemen aren’t usually hobby focal points, Muñoz’s autograph does carry respect (he doesn’t sign a ton). Beyond those, the Bengals slot lacks star power – Joe Burrow and Ja’Marr Chase are not in Topps sets at this time. A rookie like WR Andrei Iosivas (just as an example from 2023) might have autos here, but he’s a deep sleeper. In short, the Bengals don’t offer much for a breaker to get excited about in 2024 Signature – no high-demand rookie, and the vets, while iconic, appeal mostly to Bengals faithful.
Long-term upside: The Bengals’ overall trajectory is great (Burrow-Chase era), but since their key guys aren’t represented as autos in this product, that success doesn’t translate to these specific cards. The 2024 rookie class for Cincy hasn’t shown any future star yet; maybe one emerges (the Bengals have done well drafting receivers in mid-rounds historically), but that’s speculative. Boomer and Muñoz autographs will remain cool pieces for collectors, but likely flat in value. If anything, as Burrow potentially brings more success to Cincinnati, older Bengals legends might get a slight halo effect in local interest – but that’s a minor factor. There’s no obvious catalyst to drive these cards up significantly.
Recommendation: Sell. If you’re opening product and hit a Bengals legend auto, it might be worth selling or trading, as there’s probably a Bengals fan who’ll value it more in trade than it will monetarily grow over time. In breaks, Bengals might still carry mid-level pricing due to name recognition – but without Burrow/Chase autos to chase, that money is better spent elsewhere. Unless you personally collect Bengals, from an ROI standpoint it’s wise to cash out on their hits and invest in more upside elsewhere.
24. Seattle Seahawks – Sell
Key autos: Byron Murphy II (DT); Steve Largent (WR); Richard Sherman (CB); Shaun Alexander (RB)
2024 Rookies: Seattle’s 2024 draft class did not include a marquee quarterback or receiver, given they found their tackle (Charles Cross) and RB (Ken Walker) in 2022 and their CB (Devon Witherspoon) and WR (Jaxon Smith-Njigba) in 2023. In 2024, they continued rebuilding the front seven and O-line. For instance, they selected DT Byron Murphy II (not to be confused with the cornerback Byron Murphy Jr.) and LB Tyrice Knight – players who will help defensively but are virtually unknown in the card hobby. No skill-position rookie from Seattle in 2024 made waves, and thus no one is driving card demand from that class.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Seahawks’ best pulls are from their past successes. Steve Largent autographs are present (Hall of Fame WR and Seattle’s first superstar). Richard Sherman also appears (Sherman was a key member of the Legion of Boom and is quite popular, plus relatively new to having certified autos in products). Shaun Alexander, a former MVP RB, might have an auto too. These are enjoyable hits for Seahawks fans, but none are extremely valuable in the broader market – they typically sell for moderate sums (Largent’s auto value is decent but he’s also signed a fair amount in retirement). The absence of any big-name rookie or active star (DK Metcalf or Russell Wilson aren’t in this set, Wilson’s gone and Metcalf not likely included) makes the Seahawks a lower-tier draw.
Long-term upside: The Seahawks’ roster is young and strong, but their key young stars (e.g. Tariq Woolf, JSN) had their rookie cards in other sets. The 2024 rookies might become solid contributors (say one becomes a Pro Bowl DT), but even then, defensive tackles do not see a hobby spike. The team’s success could increase interest in veteran autos slightly – if Seattle makes another Super Bowl run in a couple years, nostalgia for the LOB era could tick up Sherman’s card interest, for example. But that’s speculative and marginal. Generally, Seattle’s hobby momentum will be tied to players like Geno Smith, Kenneth Walker, DK Metcalf – again, not represented with autos here. Thus, the items you pull from Seahawks in this product aren’t likely to gain significant future value.
Recommendation: Sell. For ROI purposes, you’re better off selling Seattle hits to Seahawks collectors who value them for PC. A Largent or Sherman auto will always have some demand in Seattle circles, but holding it hoping for a price surge is not a great strategy. In group breaks, the Seahawks slot can often be had cheap – and for good reason. Unless you collect the team, there’s not much reason to target or hold this team’s cards in 2024 Signature Class from an investment perspective.
25. Green Bay Packers – Sell
Key autos: MarShawn Lloyd (RB); AJ Dillon (RB, vet); Jordy Nelson (WR, legend – possibly); (No Aaron Rodgers)
2024 Rookies: The Packers went into 2024 still evaluating Jordan Love at QB, so they didn’t draft a new quarterback. They did add some offensive pieces to support him – perhaps a mid-round receiver or tight end – but the premium picks likely went to defense (Green Bay loves its defenders early) or O-line. One known rookie is RB MarShawn Lloyd, whom they took in Round 3 (as per NFLPA premiere listing). Lloyd is a talented runner from USC, but on the depth chart he sits behind Aaron Jones and AJ Dillon, so his role was minimal in 2024. No offensive rookie in Green Bay made a big splash that year.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: For a franchise as storied as the Packers, their showing in this product is underwhelming. Crucially, Aaron Rodgers is not in this set (he’s with the Jets and also not a Topps signee), and Brett Favre is also absent (Favre has legal issues and hasn’t signed cards lately). That removes the two biggest Packer autograph draws. What remains are more secondary autos: possibly a beloved receiver like Jordy Nelson or a Hall of Fame lineman like Jerry Kramer if included – nice, but not highly valued. There’s also AJ Dillon (current RB) who might have a vet auto; Dillon is a fan favorite but as a running back his hobby impact is limited. The rookie MarShawn Lloyd doesn’t have much hype behind him, so his autos are a long shot. In essence, Green Bay’s slot lacks a selling point in this set – no star rookie, and the legends we usually chase (Bart Starr, Favre, Rodgers) aren’t present.
Long-term upside: The Packers are in a transition era. If Jordan Love or any young offensive player (Dobbs, Watson from 2022 class, etc.) becomes a star, interest in Packers cards will rise – but those players’ key cards are not in this product. The 2024 class doesn’t have a likely breakout candidate; maybe a defensive player becomes a Pro Bowler, but that’s not going to drive card prices. Unless Topps secures Rodgers or Favre for future products, the Packers will remain a bit cold in terms of chase cards. Historically, Packers legends like Starr or Paul Hornung can fetch nice sums, but they aren’t in this checklist to our knowledge. So the outlook is flat.
Recommendation: Sell. Packers cards from 2024 Signature Class are not investment pieces. If you pull something like a Jordy Nelson auto, you’re best off selling it to a Packers collector who appreciates it (Jordy is very popular in Wisconsin). There’s little sense in holding onto Green Bay cards from this set waiting for a boom – the big names that cause booms aren’t there. It’s unusual to say “sell” for such a famous franchise, but in this context, the Packers slot is one to avoid or liquidate in favor of more promising teams.
26. New Orleans Saints – Sell
Key autos: Kool-Aid McKinstry (CB); Spencer Rattler (QB); Marques Colston (WR, legend); Drew Brees (QB – not in this set)
2024 Rookies: The Saints had the 14th pick in 2024 and used it on OT Taliese Fuaga, bolstering their offensive line. In Round 2, they grabbed CB Kool-Aid McKinstry (the charismatic Alabama corner). They also took a flyer on a once-hyped name: QB Spencer Rattler in Round 5. Rattler, a former Oklahoma star, had an up-and-down college career, and as a late pick he got a few spot starts when Carr was injured (as noted: 7 games, 6 starts). However, he didn’t set the world on fire and profiles more as a backup. Overall, the Saints’ class has some solid players (Fuaga should be a long-term starter, McKinstry showed potential in the secondary), but no offensive rookie that excites card collectors.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Saints’ checklist is relatively thin on star power. Drew Brees is not in this product (unfortunately, as his autos would have been a huge draw). Without Brees or Alvin Kamara (who’s active and under Panini), the Saints lean on mid-tier names. There could be autos of Marques Colston (the Saints’ all-time leading receiver) or Deuce McAllister, which are nice for Saints fans but not highly valuable in general. The rookie autos like Kool-Aid McKinstry have novelty (mostly for his memorable nickname), yet defensive back autos rarely command much value. Spencer Rattler’s autograph might actually be the most intriguing – he once had a big name, and some collectors still spec on him due to that early hype. If someone believes Rattler could eventually get a real shot, they might pay a bit for his autos. But that’s a longshot scenario. In the present, Rattler is a backup and his cards are cheap.
Long-term upside: The Saints’ franchise is in a bit of flux. Unless Rattler shocks everyone and becomes a quality NFL starter down the line, there’s no obvious hobby breakout from this class. McKinstry could be a lockdown corner – great for the team, but it won’t move card prices. Offensive tackle Fuaga could be an All-Pro and still be hobby-irrelevant. So, not much upside. The Saints spots in breaks are usually inexpensive because of this. Even a beloved player like Colston doesn’t have a huge market beyond New Orleans diehards. Should the Saints find future QB stability or success, people will mostly chase those future cards (e.g. if they draft a QB in 2025, that’ll be the hot card, not anything from 2024).
Recommendation: Sell. If you’ve got Saints autos from this product and you’re not a Saints collector, you’re likely best off selling them to someone who is. There’s limited appeal outside the fan base, and no strong indicator that will change. The Saints have a rich history (Brees, etc.), but since those key figures are missing here, this set’s Saints cards are not investment-grade. Consider moving any hits to fund teams with bigger upside.
27. Carolina Panthers – Sell
Key autos: Ja’Tavion Sanders (TE); Muhsin Muhammad (WR); Bryce Young (QB, vet – not in this set)
2024 Rookies: Carolina traded away their 2024 first-rounder in the move up for Bryce Young in 2023, so they didn’t pick until Round 2 in 2024. With that, they selected TE Ja’Tavion “JT” Sanders from Texas – a versatile receiving tight end who was one of the top TEs in the class. Sanders likely became a nice safety valve in his rookie year for Bryce, but not a focal point (line: ~30 receptions). The rest of the Panthers’ class included some defensive help (perhaps a corner or linebacker). No quarterbacks or big-name skill guys beyond Sanders (and again, TEs are a tough sell hobby-wise unless they’re generational like Pitts was or Kelce-level – Sanders isn’t at that level of hype).
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Panthers unfortunately lack exciting chase cards in this product. Their sophomore QB Bryce Young is the key to the franchise, but he has no autos in this Topps set (Panini held his rookie autos in 2023, and he’s not yet in Topps products). That removes what would have been the main draw. In his absence, we look to vets: Muhsin Muhammad might have an auto (longtime Panthers WR), but while Moose was excellent, his hobby value is modest. Perhaps Luke Kuechly could appear (he’s a popular recent-retiree), but no indication of that in the checklist snippet. The rookie JT Sanders autographs are there, but tight end autos usually don’t fly off the shelves. Unless Sanders turns into a superstar, those will stay cheap. A fun name like “Ickey” Ekwonu (2022 OT) or some defender could be in inserts, but again, not value drivers.
Long-term upside: The Panthers’ card value trajectory is almost entirely tied to Bryce Young’s development – and he’s not represented here aside from base cards perhaps. If Bryce blossoms in 2025 and beyond, interest in Panthers cards will rise, but collectors will chase his rookie-year cards (2023 products) or any autos he has, not so much a 2024 tight end. JT Sanders could become a top 10 tight end, which would be nice but probably not enough to significantly elevate his card market. Carolina’s a smaller market team in collecting, and without Cam Newton or someone flashy in this set, they remain on the low end for ROI.
Recommendation: Sell. There’s little point in holding Panthers cards from 2024 Signature Class with investment in mind. If you hit a JT Sanders auto, you might stash it on the off chance he becomes Kelce 2.0, but the odds are long. You’re better off selling/trading Panthers hits to a team collector. In breaks, the Panthers often go cheap – and even then, the expected returns are low. It’s harsh, but unless Topps secures Bryce Young autos in future sets, Panthers will remain a tough sell in the hobby for now.
28. Cleveland Browns – Sell
Key autos: Mike Hall Jr. (DT); Bernie Kosar (QB); Greg Pruitt (RB, legend); (No current star QBs)
2024 Rookies: The Browns traded away their 2024 first-rounder in the Deshaun Watson deal, so their rookie class lacked a first-round headliner. Their earliest pick (Round 2) went to DT Mike Hall Jr. from Ohio State – a local talent to plug into the defensive front. They also added LB Nathaniel “Zach” Watson in Round 3 and perhaps a developmental receiver later. No quarterbacks or marquee offensive rookies entered the fray (Cleveland was committed to Watson and had solid RB/WR depth). This class was more about filling holes and future starters on defense.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: Cleveland’s representation in this set is minimal. Bernie Kosar has an autograph in the Preeminent Ink checklist – Kosar is a beloved figure in Cleveland (he quarterbacked them in the 80s) but his cards don’t command significant value outside the region. Other possible autos could include 1980s stars like Ozzie Newsome or Greg Pruitt, which again are niche. There’s no Jim Brown auto here (that would’ve been huge, but he passed away in 2023). The Browns have no current stars signing here – Watson isn’t included, Nick Chubb is not here (and is injured anyway). So the upside of a Browns hit is maybe a nostalgic smile at a Kosar auto or a cool nod to history, but not a big monetary gain. Rookie autos like Mike Hall Jr. or others will have virtually no market (defensive tackle plus a smaller hobby market team). Even die-hard Browns collectors might not chase those aside from completeness.
Long-term upside: The Browns’ hobby hopes in general rest on if/when they ever turn the corner and contend. If Watson returns to Pro Bowl form and they make a deep playoff run, interest in Browns cards could rise some – but again, none of that is directly tied to these 2024 rookies or the signers in this product. A defensive rookie could become a Pro Bowler (Cleveland’s D is strong), but defensive Pro Bowler doesn’t equal hobby star. The best case for value increase would be if one of those autos is extremely short-printed and a Browns superfan must have it – a limited scenario. Essentially, this is one of the lower-value team sets in the product.
Recommendation: Sell. Browns cards from this set are best moved to Browns fans who will appreciate them more. There’s not much reason to hold from an investment perspective. If you end up with Cleveland in a break, you’re likely looking at sentimental pieces over profit. Sell or trade those Kosars and others to build capital for more promising teams. Browns fans are loyal, so you can likely find a taker – but outside that circle, these cards will languish.
29. Houston Texans – Sell
Key autos: Kedon Slovis (QB); Arian Foster (RB); Nolan Cromwell (Coach/DB, legend)
2024 Rookies: Houston was without a first-round pick in 2024, having traded it to Arizona in their aggressive move up for Will Anderson Jr. in 2023. That meant no blue-chip rookie this year. They snagged players like LB Nathaniel “Tank” Watson (Day 2) and perhaps a mid-round QB project such as Kedon Slovis (Day 3) – Slovis was a college journeyman (USC/Pitt/BYU) with some name recognition but a fringe NFL prospect. The Texans’ 2024 class was generally an afterthought; their franchise rookies were really C.J. Stroud and Anderson in 2023, not 2024.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Texans’ checklist has one notable name: Arian Foster, who appears in the Preeminent Ink autos. Foster was a star RB for Houston in the early 2010s and has a bit of hobby love, but as a running back his value isn’t extremely high. Still, a low-numbered Foster auto might fetch a reasonable sum since he doesn’t sign too often nowadays. Aside from Arian, the pickings are slim. Maybe a Andre Johnson auto would have been great, but he’s not listed in what we saw. Nolan Cromwell (listed in PI) is actually a Rams legend who coached for the Texans – not a card that many will chase. The rookie autos include Kedon Slovis, but as a late-round QB who may not even make the roster long-term, his auto is more of a curiosity than a hit. In sum, the Texans lack any of the exciting young stars in this product – Stroud’s rookie cards are all Panini (and he’s absent here). Without Stroud or even a notable vet like J.J. Watt (retired, not signing here), there’s just not much to draw value.
Long-term upside: The Texans’ actual long-term outlook is promising because of Stroud – he had a stellar rookie year in 2023, and if he continues to ascend, the Texans franchise will gain hobby prominence. But again, Stroud’s not in this product, so that rising tide won’t lift 2024 Signature Class Texans cards much, if at all. Perhaps if Slovis sticks around and, in a wild scenario, becomes a starter or trade asset, his autos could rise from the ashes, but that’s an extreme long shot. The likely scenario is none of the 2024 Texans rookies become stars, and their cards remain commons. Arian Foster’s legacy is set, and his card values will probably remain where they are – moderate.
Recommendation: Sell. There’s little reason to hold Texans cards from this release hoping for a future payoff. If you pull an Arian Foster auto, you might get a decent price now from a Texans fan or a set collector – take it. Any other hits, move them if you can, or use them as throw-ins in trades. The Texans simply don’t offer enough in this set to justify holding as an investment piece.
30. New York Jets – Sell
Key autos: None of note (Day-2 OL pick, maybe); Wayne Chrebet (WR, legend); Vinny Testaverde (QB, legend)
2024 Rookies: The Jets’ 2024 season was defined by Aaron Rodgers’ brief appearance and injury, rather than rookie contributions. They picked mid-first, perhaps bolstering the O-line with someone like OT Olu Fashanu (Penn State) to protect Rodgers – a smart team move, but an offensive lineman does nothing for the card hobby. In Round 2 or 3 they might have added a receiver or depth corner. No quarterback was drafted (Rodgers was acquired for this window, and they had Zach Wilson as a backup). So, the Jets’ class, while it may have addressed needs, was not flashy. The most notable could be Fashanu if he turns into a Pro Bowl tackle, but again, that’s not something collectors chase on cardboard.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: This product offers very slim pickings for Jets fans or anyone else. No Aaron Rodgers autos here (he’s with the Packers historically, and Topps didn’t have him anyway). There’s also no Garrett Wilson or Sauce Gardner autos in this set, as they are active stars under Panini contracts. Thus, we look to older names: possibly Wayne Chrebet, the beloved underdog receiver of the 90s, or Vinny Testaverde, who had a Pro Bowl run with the Jets – if they have autos here, those are mildly interesting but low in monetary value (Chrebet is a cult hero in NY, but outside Jets circles not so much). Maybe Joe Klecko or other New York Sack Exchange members if Topps included them, but nothing indicates that in the checklist snippet. The bottom line is the Jets don’t have a big autograph draw in Signature Class 2024. Even their rookies – for example, if OL Fashanu signed – as a top tackle he’s great on the field but will not be sought in the hobby.
Long-term upside: The Jets’ hobby relevance in the near future will depend on Aaron Rodgers’ comeback or finding a new QB, and the continued stardom of players like Garrett Wilson and Sauce Gardner. None of those angles involve this product’s checklist. A great left tackle might help the team make the playoffs in 2025, but it won’t make his rookie auto a hot item. Unless Topps lands Rodgers autos down the line (perhaps if he retires and does legend deals), Jets hits will remain sparse. And if Rodgers does something miraculous in 2025, people will clamor for his autos (which would be in other sets or older Green Bay memorabilia, not this). So, no real upside here.
Recommendation: Sell. Any Jets cards you get from 2024 Signature are likely better off sold to a Jets team collector. There’s just not enough star power or rookie juice to justify hanging onto them. The Jets slot is, frankly, one of the worst for ROI in this product – it’s almost all base and filler with maybe a nostalgic auto that a hardcore fan will appreciate. If you find someone building a master set or a Jets fan, move your Jets hits to them and allocate resources to more promising teams.
31. Los Angeles Chargers – Sell
Key autos: Joe Alt (OT); Junior Seau (LB, legend); Kellen Winslow Sr. (TE, legend)
2024 Rookies: The Chargers had the #5 overall pick in 2024 and used it on OT Joe Alt from Notre Damechargers.com – a technically sound, high-upside left tackle to protect Justin Herbert. It was a savvy football pick (Alt was considered one of the best OL prospects in years), but for card collectors, an offensive lineman at 5 is about as quiet as it gets. In later rounds, the Bolts added some receivers and defensive depth (perhaps a Day 2 WR like Decamerion Richardson – though he’s actually a CB mentioned for LV – or others). Essentially, the Chargers drafted for needs, not hobby headlines, in 2024. No new quarterback or skill star means the class isn’t moving products.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: With Justin Herbert and others under Panini’s domain in 2024, the Chargers in this Topps set don’t have their current star autos. Instead, you might pull a legend like Junior Seau or Kellen Winslow Sr. if they’re included – both Hall of Very Good players with some fan following, but not huge spenders chasing them. (Seau is beloved in San Diego, and his auto is meaningful since he tragically passed in 2012 – if Topps included a cut or sticker of Seau, that would actually be a cool rare hit, but we have no evidence of it here). There’s also perhaps LaDainian Tomlinson or Dan Fouts potential, but again, not indicated in the known checklist portion and probably not included. The most prominent name we see is Andre Rison but he’s listed under Falcons, not Chargers. So really, aside from maybe a Seau sighting, the Chargers offer Joe Alt’s rookie auto (which most breakers will shrug at) and not much else. Alt will likely be an excellent player protecting Herbert’s blindside, but even the best tackles (e.g. Trent Williams) have virtually no hobby market.
Long-term upside: The Chargers team is built around Herbert, and as he goes, so does collector interest. None of the 2024 rookies affect that equation (unless one of the mid-round receivers becomes a star target for Herbert, which is possible but speculative). Joe Alt might make Pro Bowls, but offensive linemen are hobby ghosts. So we can’t expect any surge in card value from this class. If the Chargers finally go on a deep playoff run in the coming years, people will chase Herbert, Allen, Ekeler, etc., not these rookies. The only slight caveat: if somewhere in the product there’s a dual auto or special insert featuring a Charger legend, that could have some long-term appeal (e.g. a rare LT/Gates dual auto would be nice). But focusing on what’s likely, the Chargers slot is pretty dry.
Recommendation: Sell. In terms of ROI, the Chargers are near the bottom. If you land a Chargers auto that isn’t an unexpected legend, it’s probably Joe Alt or another non-marquee name – you’re best off selling it or using it as trade fodder. Chargers fans exist, but even they aren’t clamoring for a lineman’s autograph. This is a spot you avoid if you’re chasing value, and if you end up with it, you offload and put those funds towards a team with more collectible players.
32. Jacksonville Jaguars – Sell
Key autos: Graham Barton (OL); Fred Taylor (RB, legend); Mark Brunell (QB, legend)
2024 Rookies: Jacksonville picked late in Round 1 due to their 2023 playoff run. They opted to shore up the offensive line by drafting C Graham Barton from Duke at pick 26. Barton was arguably the top center in the class and started all 16 games (a solid but unglamorous contribution). In later rounds, the Jags added depth at linebacker and maybe a backup skill position. They were already set at QB with Trevor Lawrence and at RB/WR with Etienne and Ridley, so no splashy rookie additions on offense. This class was fundamentally boring from a card perspective – necessary pieces for the team’s success, but no “hero” players that collectors chase.
2024 Topps Signature Class Break value: The Jaguars slot has very little in the way of high-value hits. There are a couple of franchise icons that could appear: Fred Taylor, the long-time star running back, and Mark Brunell, the QB who led them in the 90s. If those autos are in the product, they are nice nostalgia pulls for Jags fans but have limited market value beyond that. (Fred Taylor is somewhat underrated historically; his autos don’t go for huge money but Jaguars faithful like him). Aside from that, the rookies like Graham Barton or any others (a Day 2 corner or receiver like Parker Washington maybe) are not going to carry any worth. The Jaguars also don’t have any current vets signing in this (no Lawrence auto – that would have been massive, but that’s not happening yet with Topps). So essentially, this is one of the weakest team checklists in terms of exciting content.
Long-term upside: The Jaguars as a team have a bright future with Trevor Lawrence at the helm. If he becomes a superstar and the Jags contend for Super Bowls, the franchise’s cards in general will rise in profile. However, the specific cards from this set won’t be the ones reaping that benefit – people will be after Lawrence’s rookie autos (2021) or even his eventual vet autos once Fanatics gets him in products. A center like Graham Barton could be a 10-year stalwart and still never be reflected in card value. There is virtually no scenario where a 2024 Jaguars Signature Class card becomes hotly sought after, barring a miracle like an unknown rookie turning into an All-Pro skill player (and none of their 2024 picks fit that profile on offense).
Recommendation: Sell. The Jaguars rank last in expected ROI here. If you pull a Brunell or Taylor auto and you’re not attached to it, sell it – those are easier to reacquire later if needed. There’s just no sense holding Jags cards from this set from an investment viewpoint. Convert them into cash or trade for cards of emerging players. Jaguars team collectors might want those legends, but their numbers are fewer compared to big-market teams. All in all, Jacksonville is a sell/avoid for 2024 Topps Signature Class – save your dollars for greener (or more orange, blue, red, etc.) pastures.